Every brand team has written the sentence. For a defined audience, we are the category that delivers the defining difference — the frame is taught in every marketing programme, mine included, and it produces a small, polished paragraph that everyone in the room can recite. Then the brand goes out into the wild, and the wild edits it. I have come to believe that positioning statements rarely fail because they are badly written. They fail because they are not the thing they claim to describe. [author assertion]
A positioning statement is a promise drafted by a committee. A brand, as customers actually encounter it, is something else: it is what the firm's behaviour teaches them to expect. Customers do not read statements. They read the product that shipped late, the support reply that took four days, the price that contradicted the premium story, the update that removed the feature they loved. Each of these acts is a copy edit performed on the brand by the only editors whose revisions count. [author assertion]
The wild kills statements in predictable ways. The difference the statement names turns out to be one the operations cannot deliver at scale. The audience the statement targets turns out to buy for reasons the research politely concealed. The competitor the statement defines itself against simply ignores the frame and competes on another axis entirely. None of these is a communications failure. All of them arrive dressed as one, because the statement is the artefact the organisation knows how to revise. [author assertion]
Where statements genuinely earn their keep is inside the firm. A good positioning statement is a coordination device — a decision rule that a product manager, a service agent and a pricing analyst can each apply, alone, at midnight, and arrive at roughly the same answer. Judged as advertising, most statements are fiction. Judged as internal law, the best of them are excellent. The tragedy is that firms keep score on the wrong function: they polish the sentence for the customer who will never read it, instead of testing whether the employee can use it. [author assertion]
So here is the exercise I now assign, in place of the traditional one. Take the last hundred customer-facing decisions your organisation actually made — the shipments, the refusals, the prices, the apologies — and write the positioning statement they imply. Then place it beside the official one. The distance between the two documents is your brand strategy problem, stated honestly, and closing that distance is almost never a writing task. [author assertion]
Brands as promises are liabilities, because promises are graded on delivery by people who did not attend the workshop. Brands as behaviour are assets, because behaviour is what compounds. Manage the behaviour. Let the statement follow, cap in hand, and be pleasantly surprised when it turns out to be true. [author assertion]
