Here is a sentence I put on the board in the first week of term, and then spend the term defending: most of your market has never thought about you, is not thinking about you now, and will buy you anyway — on the day they need the category, from the small set of names they can bring to mind. Marketing that cannot accommodate this sentence will keep designing ceremonies for an audience that is not attending. [author assertion]
The industry prefers a different portrait: the engaged prospect, moving through stages, consuming content, warming. I understand the preference; I taught the staircase myself. But the arithmetic of every mature category I have examined tells the colder story. Most buyers are light buyers. They purchase rarely, from several brands, with low attention and lower loyalty, and they constitute the majority of every brand's sales and nearly all of its growth. The heavy buyer your dashboard loves is real, and is nearly the whole of what your instruments can see, which is why your strategy keeps being written for the visible minority. [author assertion]
This is the funnel's deepest artefact, deeper than the stitching I have complained about elsewhere: not the shape of the journey but the casting of the customer. Our instruments are built from the people who respond, click, attend, and answer surveys. The light buyer leaves almost no thread to stitch, so the strategy is written in a room from which most of the market is absent, about a customer who is unusually interested in us. We then express surprise that campaigns perform in the dashboard and dissipate in the market. [author assertion]
What works, on the evidence I trust, is undramatic to the point of embarrassment. Be easy to bring to mind in the situations where the category is bought — which means breadth, repetition, and distinctive assets refreshed patiently over years, not intensity aimed at the already-convinced. Be easy to buy wherever the need occurs. Accept that most exposures will land on people who do nothing, because "nothing, this year" is what most of a growing brand's audience is for. This programme will not fit on one slide, flatters no one's media plan, and has the additional defect of being roughly true. [author assertion]
I am not against engagement; I am against mistaking the engaged for the market. If your brand has a devoted minority, treat them well — they are customers too. But do not let their visibility set your strategy's centre of gravity, because a brand grows at its edges, in the minds of people who are, at this moment, thinking about something else entirely — which is to say, nearly everyone you will ever sell to. [author assertion]
So the question I leave with every brand team I teach: when did you last design for the buyer who will think about you for four seconds, two years from now, in a shop you will never see — and what, exactly, did you expect those four seconds to contain? [author assertion]
